Lie detector tests, or polygraphs, have long been used as a tool to determine whether someone is telling the truth. However, these tests are far from foolproof. Many people fail lie detector tests for reasons that go beyond simple dishonesty. Factors like anxiety and physiological responses can lead to a polygraph failure while things like victimization, prior behaviors, and poor testing conditions can negatively affect newer technologies.
Ultimately, no technology is 100% accurate. But understanding how various technologies work can make it possible to improve outcomes.
The Mechanics of a Lie Detector Test
Polygraph tests measure physiological indicators such as heart rate, respiration, and skin conductivity while a person answers questions. The idea is that lying induces stress, which causes measurable changes in these physical responses. However, these physiological responses can be triggered by various factors unrelated to dishonesty.
Common Reasons for Failing a Polygraph Test
-
Anxiety and Nervousness: One of the most common reasons people fail a polygraph test is anxiety. Many people experience nervousness, especially in high-stakes situations like job screenings, criminal investigations, or legal disputes. The pressure to "pass" the test itself can induce physiological changes that mimic the stress responses associated with lying. For instance, if someone is particularly anxious about the possibility of failing, their elevated heart rate or rapid breathing could be interpreted as signs of deception—even if they’re telling the truth.
-
Misinterpretation of Results: Polygraphs measure physiological responses, but they don’t directly measure lies. It’s up to the examiner to interpret the data, and human error can occur in this process. A nervous response to an irrelevant question or even the baseline questions (control questions) could lead the examiner to conclude that the person is being deceptive. This subjectivity makes it possible for people to fail a lie detector test, even when they are innocent.
-
False Positives and False Negatives: Just as some truthful people may fail a polygraph test, some deceptive individuals may pass. These false positives and negatives occur because not everyone reacts to lying in the same way. Some people can remain calm and composed while lying, which prevents the polygraph from picking up significant physiological changes. Conversely, truthful people may experience stress for reasons unrelated to lying, causing a false positive result.
-
Physical Conditions or Medications: Certain medical conditions, like heart problems or anxiety disorders, can affect a person’s physiological responses and potentially skew polygraph results. Medications that influence heart rate, blood pressure, or respiration, such as beta-blockers or anti-anxiety drugs, can also make the results less reliable. Someone with a naturally high heart rate or irregular breathing pattern could fail the test, even if they’re not being deceptive.
Ocular Motor Deception Detection (ODD)
A new development in lie detection technology is ocular motor deception detection (ODD). This method tracks eye movements, pupil dilation, and blinking patterns to determine whether someone is lying. ODD is based on the idea that lying requires more cognitive effort than telling the truth, and this additional effort causes detectable changes in eye movement and pupil response.
How ODD Works
When people lie, their cognitive load increases because they need to create and maintain a false narrative. ODD technology measures how the eyes respond to this mental strain. For example, when someone lies, their pupils may dilate, or their blink rate may increase as they subconsciously struggle to keep their story straight. Additionally, the eyes may show longer fixation times on certain questions as the brain processes the deceptive response.
Why People Fail ODD Tests
-
Cognitive Strain from Stress:
While less so than polygraphs, ODD can be sensitive to stress and anxiety, which can also increase cognitive load. Even if someone is telling the truth, the anxiety of being tested can cause changes in their eye movements and pupil dilation, leading to a failed test. -
Causes of Cognitive Load
Cognitive load can be caused by things other than lying. Some of the most common are listed below. These are some things that can cause an innocent person to fail an ODD test:
-
being a victim of or witness to a serious crime or act
-
committing a similar crime or act
-
enabling someone else or facilitated the crime or act
-
covering for someone involved in a crime or act
-
while testing, worrying about another serious crime
-
misunderstanding the test questions
-
intimidation by external circumstances before or during testing
-
Normal Variability in Eye Movements:
Just as with physiological responses in polygraph tests, individual variability in eye movements can affect the accuracy of ODD tests. Some people naturally have more active eyes—frequent blinking, larger pupils, or erratic gaze patterns—that aren’t necessarily linked to deception.
Accuracy of Lie Detection Methods
No lie detection technology is 100% accurate. Polygraph accuracy ranges from 65% to 85%, depending on the quality of the human examiner. ODD technology, though still relatively new, shows very promising results with accuracy rates of 80-95%.
Conclusion
People fail lie detector tests—whether polygraphs or ODD—for a variety of reasons that don’t always point to dishonesty. Anxiety, medical conditions, nervousness, and even the natural variability in physiological or ocular responses can all contribute to a failed result. While lie detection technologies can offer insight into a person’s truthfulness, they are not infallible, and the results should always be interpreted with caution. Ultimately, the limitations of these methods underscore the complexity of human behavior and the difficulty of uncovering deception with absolute certainty.